People for Pet OWNership

Click here to edit subtitle


How Many Sides to a Story?

Posted by P4PO on May 20, 2020 at 3:00 PM

Provided by a Guest Writer, with the Breeder's accounting of her story.

Who remembers Peg Shaw, the Chinese Crested Breeder in Nebraska? We saw the harassment posted all over the internet from a buyer, and someone who quite frankly couldn’t figure out if they were her attorney or not. Peg sold a puppy that ended up having an eye issue, and compliance with the state lemon law was not good enough for this buyer. As big of a splash as they made, things went silent for a while. No longer. Lawsuits have been filed and Peg is fighting back. See the timeline below and court documents attached.


Timeline of Events:

Tuesday, Sept. 24, 2019 - Nikki picks up the 1st puppy Cujo. Nikki states that there was green discharge coming from his left eye.

Friday, Dec. 13, 2019 - Peg sends photo of the 2nd replacement puppy to Nikki.

Thursday, Dec. 19, 2019 - 2nd replacement puppy is shipped by Peg to Nikki.

Thursday, Dec. 19, 2019 - Nikki sends a text message to Peg with photo of the 2nd replacement puppy asking why the 2nd puppy's eyes are 'crusty' like the first puppy Cujo. 

Friday, Dec. 29, 2019 - Nikki Andrews creates a GoFundMe Page for the 1st puppy, Cujo, asking for donations to pay for eye surgery and bad mouthing the breeder, Peg Shaw. Nikki Andrews was originally asking for donations of $58,000. 

Saturday, Dec. 20, 2019 - Peg sends a text message to Nikki asking Nikki to send back the 2nd puppy and that she will refund the purchase cost and shipping upon receipt/return of the 2nd puppy. Peg also asks Nikki to remove all negative posts made about her.

Monday, Dec 21, 2019 - Nancy Guttenberg, 'outspoken' New York attorney gets involved in the puppy debacle. Nikki and Nancy both say that Nancy is representing her, only for Nancy to come back and say she’s not. The harassment by Nancy continues today.




Around January 2, 2020 - Nancy Guttenberg OR Nikki Andrews makes 'threats' to Peg Shaw about calling Animal Control or the Dept. of Agriculture to have Peg's kennels inspected.

January 2020 - Nikki Andrews, the puppy buyer, files a Consumer Complaint with the Nebraska Attorney General's Office against Peg Shaw for 2 defective puppies.

Friday, Jan. 3, 2020 - Peg goes "public" in two dog groups on Facebook. One post was removed - while the second post remained up.

Saturday, Jan. 4, 2020 - Nikki sends private messages stating that she spoke with the Nebraska Attorney General Jan 3 and will be forwarding information regarding the post on the fake go fund me.

January 3-4, 2020 - Nancy states that she is establishing a non-profit 501c for Nikki.

Wednesday, Feb. 5, 2020 - Peg Shaw posts on Facebook to a group "Chinese Crested Uncensored" reproduced on Nikki's GoFundMe page.

Saturday, Feb. 9, 2020 - Nikki posts on the GoFundMe page a photo of the 2nd replacement puppy with a whiteboard behind her written - IVDD (spine/back) at risk affected, carrier Dilated Cardiomyopathy, Eye surgery quote $4,200-$4,400.

Saturday, Feb. 9, 2020 - Nikki posts on the GoFundMe page a photo of the 1st puppy Cujo with a whiteboard behind her written - IVDD (spine/back) at risk affected, carrier Dilated Cardiomyopathy, Eye surgery completed.

In March/April 2020 - Annalee Philomy purchased a show prospect puppy from Peg after Nikki got Cujo, the 1st puppy. Annalee then claimed that the puppy was not show quality. Peg said “Fine, agree to neuter him and I will refund you the purchase price”. Annalee refused to neuter the puppy. Then the next thing you know Nikki Andrews has signed on as a co-owner of Annalee’s non-show prospect pup.

 Monday, March 9, 2020 - Nikki sent a text message to Peg arguing about receiving AKC paperwork. Peg reminded Nikki that she will release the AKC paperwork when Nikki provides proof of spay/neuter on the two puppies.

Around March 2020 - Nikki Andrews AND Annalee McPhilomy FILE a lawsuit against Peg Shaw, the breeder in Saline county, Nebraska.

Sunday, March 22, 2020 - Nancy Guttenberg continues to make posts about Peg Shaw

Court Documents - Lawsuits and Counter Complaints:



Categories: None